History of Modern Palestine - 800 Words

In his book, A History of Modern Palestine, Ilan Pappe attempts to add to the discussion of the struggle between Jews and their counterparts over the idea of Israeli state. Using documents that have been released by the Israeli secret service that one of his graduate students had found, Pappe attempts to paint a â€Å"new history of the conflict† in the Middle East. His books adds a new element to the argument. The documents, released in the late 1980s, but the US, UN, and Israeli government show that the state of Israel was not completely innocent in the 1940s conflict. While history usually is written by the victors, Pappe, known for being critical of Israel and it policies, writes an alternate history. The questions becomes, does he do the†¦show more content†¦Instead of focusing on those who influenced and the decisions, like most modern of his peers and other professionals in his field, he focuses, rather, on â€Å"the others† as he put in it in the abov e quote. He view on them, is the idea that their story while important, is equally to those who are more informed. Pappe views the heroes as the invaded, such as women, children, peasants, workers, ordinary city dwellers, peaceniks, human rights activists.† The bad people in history are looked as â€Å"the arrogant generals leading the troops, the greedy politicians† stealing from the poor, the â€Å"cynical statesmen† and the â€Å"misogynist men† who cared nothing of the well-being of the women (Pappe, xix). As one reads along, the problem with the way that is written becomes more apparent. The one that are eventually identified in the negative are mostly Jewish. When writing a historical narrative, especially on such a divisive issue, like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This has some very negative consequences. It may come off as looking anti-Semitic. Especially in some more extreme extents of Islam, this is highly ironic. In some forms of Islam, women are ruled and regulated into third class citizens. While in class, Dr. Omid has mentioned this by pointing out that many religions have their faults, Pappe seems to skim over this and point out Israel’s faults without looking at some of the Palestinians own behaviors towards women. There areShow MoreRelatedEssay880 Words   |  4 Pagestime in 2017 was devoted to research. I have a number of major projects that require extensive research. My project for a co-authored book on the photographic albums of Palestine before 1948, led me to Beirut several times where I spent considerable time researching at archives and private collections. I also used my time in Palestine, and my visits to Jordan, during the summer to work on the same research project and unearth new collections. The book is under contract with University of CaliforniaRead MoreA Brief Note On The Arab Israeli War1203 Words   |  5 PagesModern Essay Arab and Israeli Conflict The Middle Eastern area has experienced and suffered more conflict and blood shed than probably any part of the world. The Arab-Israeli war in 1948 was the first step of a century of bloody and hostile conflicts. The Arab- Israeli war was caused by a number of factors both intraregional and international, which created a catalyst of war through a complex situation. This was triggered by Israel’s independence declaration in 14 May 1948; in the Arab-IsraeliRead MoreRoman Military Essay1595 Words   |  7 PagesThe distinct similarities of the Roman Military to that of modern militaries, the history of their conquest and duties, and their influence on Christianity are the attributes that influenced the entire world. Ancient civilization at its core was a very brutal time. Hollywood at times portrays military battles being fought by mob like soldiers with no clear organization. The Roman military was something quite different. Like modern military’s Roman armies did have standing formations with ‘regimental’Read MoreThe Palestinian Conflict Of The Middle East1654 Words   |  7 PagesIsraeli-Palestinian Conflict The creation of two sovereign states is the only possibility of a peaceful end to the conflict over historical Palestine in the Middle East. To achieve this, a third-party must offer enough incentive to both the Arabic and Jewish states and create a sovereign Palestinian state. This is not a very probable outcome, as the conflict is rooted in the peoples’ traditions and beliefs making it much harder to compromise. I predict this conflict will end in the overwhelmingRead MoreThe Conflict Of The Arab Israeli Conflict1420 Words   |  6 Pagescauses of the Arab-Israeli conflict; all of which seek to discern the culprit and contrive a remedy. The story behind this age old conflict is, as quoted by Israeli historian Illan Pappe, â€Å"the simple but horrific story of the ethnic cleansing of Palestine† (qtd. In â€Å"The Catastrophe†). As such, thorough review of the causes behind this ethnocentric conflict is vital in understanding the tumultuous power struggle in I srael and the violent instability of the region as a whole. While many believe theRead MoreIsrael Palestine Panel Reflection Paper852 Words   |  4 Pages Israel-Palestine Panel Reflection I grew up in a world with little insight into the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. I knew that it was an issue emblazoned in thousands of years of history and that, for the most part, each side blamed the other side for the conflict. However, rom what I did know prior to the panel, I had been unable to view the conflict in the Middle East from either a pro-Israel or a pro-Palestine light—both groups have committed atrocities, and both groups have been the targetsRead MoreThe Creation Of The Jewish State As Part Of Palestine1281 Words   |  6 Pagesto be the holiest city in the world. A lot of people think that United Nations were the one who gave birth to Israel, however in reality the United Nations General Assembly recommended the creation of the Jewish state as part of Palestine. Many events in the Jewish history gave purpose to create Israel. The most important were Zionism and Holocaust, as well as end of the Second World War, where French and British have their influence on Arab world. Genocide of the European Jews was at the horror pointRead MoreArab Israeli Conflict 883 Words   |  4 Pages1.1 WHAT IS THE ARAB ISRAELI CONFLICT? The Arab-Israeli conflict is a hotly contested issue both in the Middle East and the broader global community.1 The modern conflict is essentially a dispute over the area known up until 1948 as Palestine, which is considered holy to all three major monotheistic religions.2 The primary parties in the conflict are Israeli (formerly Zionist) Jews and Palestinian Arabs (who are predominately Muslim).3 It is one of the unresolved problems bequeathed to the regionRead MoreThe Arab Israeli Conflict Between Islam And Judaism Essay1466 Words   |  6 PagesZionism and Arab Nationalism, showcase the emerging question of identity during the 19th and 20th centuries. The Arab states, long ruled by Western colonial powers, emerged from the Mandate system weak and powerless. Why British troops did not leave Palestine until May 1st, 1948. Prior to this, the British proclaimed their support for a Jewish state through the Balfour Declaration (1917). In 1947 the United Nations released resolution no. 181 which created two states, one Palestinian-Arab, and one JewishRead MoreThe Arab Israeli War ( 1948-49 ) A Political Conflict?1719 Words   |  7 PagesLuke Horsley Preliminary Modern History Mr. Powell Historical Investigation â€Å"To what extent was the First Arab-Israeli War (1948-49) a political conflict?† WORD COUNT: 1388 In order to assess to what extent the First Arab-Israeli war was a political conflict, a working definition of ‘political conflict’ is needed. In this essay, the phrase ‘political conflict ’ refers to conflict motivated or influenced by a nation’s government or by the power, interests and security